Jan 9, 2015 06:05PM Zillsnot4me wrote:
I have the same question! Awaiting someone more knowledgable's reply.
Posted on: Jan 9, 2015 01:22PM
Many sites suggest turmeric (or curcumin) may have anti-inflammatory and anti-cancer properties, among other benefits. However, WebMD states:
"Hormone-sensitive condition such as breast cancer, uterine cancer, ovarian cancer, endometriosis, or uterine fibroids: Turmeric might act like estrogen. If you have any condition that might be made worse by exposure to estrogen, don't use turmeric." However, I know several MDs who use it themselves.
Has anyone discussed this with their MD or have any insight to contribute to this question?
Posts 1 - 30 (69 total)
Jan 9, 2015 06:05PM Zillsnot4me wrote:
I have the same question! Awaiting someone more knowledgable's reply.
Jan 9, 2015 06:14PM SoLinda wrote:
Yikes! I eat this every day on my salad!!! I make a paste of the curcumin root (I grow it at home and also have turmeric powder which I buy at the grocery store) mixed with garlic, black pepper and olive oil. I REALLY hope it is ok. for me to eat this as my cancer was estrogen and progesterone positive ...
Awaiting a response from someone more knowledgeable please.
Jan 9, 2015 08:40PM Obxflygirl1 wrote:
everything I have read for,the last two years says tumeric is an anti-cancer substance. I also mix tumeric with pepper and olive oil. This is the first I have heard of this. If you google tumeric and cancer, everything says it has anti - estrogen benefits. Sure hope someone comes and sets the record straight. Moderators or Dr. Weiss ?
Jan 9, 2015 09:11PM coraleliz wrote:
My MO is OK with me taking Turmeric. I take it because it helps the arthritis pain in my hands.
Jan 9, 2015 09:18PM formydaughter wrote:
I just got the go ahead from my MO this week to take tumeric. I'm ER+. But he is not necessarily aware of all food issues, since this is not his focus. I'd like to hear from someone in the know as well!
Jan 9, 2015 10:20PM Hopeful82014 wrote:I suspect that for most other types of cancers turmeric is not a bad idea at all - in fact, it's probably a very good idea. It's probably even safe for TNs. However, most people writing on this topic aren't as aware as some of us need to be of the issues around estrogen. I'm very cautious due to the phytoestrogens and have NO idea how much impact they would have nor how much might be safe - or otherwise. I would love for someone reliably knowledgable to weigh in on this topic.
Jan 10, 2015 12:01AM heartnsoul76 wrote:
Well, for pete's sake!
I guess I'll quit adding it to my salads and sandwiches until this is clarified a bit more.
This website (Food for Breast Cancer) also said it can interfere with tamoxifen's effectiveness: http://foodforbreastcancer.com/foods/turmeric
I never thought it could be BAD for us!
Jan 10, 2015 02:16AM coraleliz wrote:
hopeful- can you provide the link to the WebMD page. I tried to use the search feature at that site but couldn't find that quote. Maybe, just maybe they site some references
Jan 10, 2015 10:38AM leggo wrote:
JMO, but there are so many foods that have estrogenic effects that you can't possibly avoid them all and I think that's ok. Those phytoestrogens in that tiny amount just float around in your plasma and are excreted in your urine before it can do any damage. The dangerous thing about phytoestrogen food is foods that contain genestein. That seems to be the isoflavin that binds to receptors and promote estrogen fueled tumor growth. The highest concentration of genistein is found in soy and fava beans. I would just avoid those.
Jan 10, 2015 11:10AM - edited Jan 10, 2015 11:14AM by leggo
Should clarify, the other isolaflavins bind too, just not like soy (and fava beans).Soy isoflavins tend to actually "seek" out the estrogen receptors, which I think, makes it dangerous for ER+ bc. Again, JMO.
Jan 10, 2015 01:08PM Hopeful82014 wrote:Leg go - that's interesting info. Can you cite some foundation for it? I don't doubt you but would be interested in the background :)
Jan 10, 2015 02:12PM leggo wrote:
Hopeful, believe me, it's ok to doubt me. I wouldn't believe anything I read unless I checked it out first. Unfortunately, no, I can't link to any studies or articles for what I said above. Just stuff I remember reading overthe years. I suppose some of this info might show up on Google though. I know Wikipedia usually does a good job of showing the chemistry behind stuff so maybe on there? Also, when it comes to soy, some of that is probably just my own bias and I have a pretty closed mind on soy....filthy, disgusting, toxic product. I'm sure WebMD wouldn't be giving out arbitrary info. If it says turmeric is estrogenic, I'd tend to believe that, but like I said, the question for me is how much.....to me, a little is ok...avoiding all would be impossible. Just how I feel about it with no actual proof to back it up.
Jan 10, 2015 02:34PM - edited Jan 10, 2015 02:36PM by Hopeful82014I agree with you 100 percent on soy - much as I like some forms of it, I've avoided it for a long time. It's too bad; soy butter was my substitute for nut butters :( I'm going to look at Wikipedia, although chemistry is NOT my strong suit.
Jan 10, 2015 03:43PM Hopeful82014 wrote:
Coraleliz (and others): Here's the link: http://www.webmd.com/vitamins-supplements/ingredie...
Once you get there, click on the tab labeled 'Side Effects' and the discussion copied above is about mid-way down. There is a drop down for clinical references and citations. I've looked it over and didn't see a cite that stood out regarding phytoestrogenic qualities but I did not go over it with a fine-tooth comb, either.
Jan 11, 2015 02:46AM - edited Jan 11, 2015 03:59AM by Momine
I found this, rather old, study, which looked for genistein and daidzein in common foods. It concludes that raisins have the highest content: http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/11002128
This article is full text, from 2006, and has an extensive list of foods: http://journals.cambridge.org/download.php?file=%2FBJN%2FBJN84_05%2FS0007114500002075a.pdf&code=23672eae167c70557fc0936b8a4b398c
In the beginning of all this BC fun, I became very paranoid about phytoestrogens. However, all the foods that are supposed to be good for you seem to have high levels of phytoestrogens. So, what to do? I basically avoid any kind of processed and messed with food and stick to food that is in its original form, as far as possible. I use a range of herbs and spices, lots of herbs usually.
I eat quite a lot of legumes: lentils, chick peas etc. Soy beans are not part of that, mainly because I never ate them. Also, I do not eat meat substitutes or protein powders and the like. It may be crunchy-granola, but it is still highly processed and not "real" food.
Then I found this on NYU Langone Medical Center site:
"Like other phytoestrogens, genistein can work in two ways: either by increasing or decreasing the effects of estrogen. This happens because genistein binds to special sites on cells called estrogen receptors. Genistein stimulates these receptors, but not as strongly as real estrogen; at the same time, it blocks estrogen itself from attaching. The net result is that when there is a lot of estrogen in the body, such as before menopause, genistein may partly block its effects. Since estrogen appears to increase the risk of various forms of cancer, regular use of genistein by premenopausal women might help reduce this risk. On the other hand, if there is little human estrogen present, such as after menopause, genistein can partly make up for it. This is one rationale for using genistein to treat menopausal symptoms and to prevent osteoporosis." http://www.med.nyu.edu/content?ChunkIID=21734
This makes a lot of sense, and it would suggest that menopausal status is an important consideration in all this.
Finally, after initially taking various supplements, I now stick to a small calcium and D supplement and probiotics. It seems to me that high doses of anything have the potential to have adverse effects and interactions.
Jan 11, 2015 04:50AM Momine wrote:
Oh, and then there is this:
No wonder many of us are confused.
Jan 11, 2015 06:02AM Teakie88 wrote:
I take tumeric/curcumin in tablet form everyday, and it already contains the black pepper in it. I purchase mine from Amazon made by Dr. Danielle's. It's kind of pricey, but it saves me from having to mess with mixing up a dosage myself. Curcumin serves as an anti-inflammatory so that your immune system works better to fend off illness and possibly diseases like cancer. It has antioxidant and antitumor properties and has been in use for something like 5.000 years for medicinal purposes. Ann
Jan 11, 2015 01:17PM leggo wrote:
Again, JMHO, but I think a lot of the benefits/risks are related to individual hormonal status of bc and if you've still got working ovaries or not. It's probably not as complicated an issue for other cancers. Breast cancer has way too many variables.
Jan 11, 2015 02:07PM Hopeful82014 wrote:"Breast cancer has way too many variables"
That's for sure, leggo!
I read a couple of these studies this a.m. and there is a LOT of fascinating information in them (thanks so much, Momine and Kayb). However, I saw no reference anywhere to the hormone receptor status of any of the bc cells they were using. Now, maybe it doesn't make a difference, but I'd like to see researchers at least acknowledge that results could be influenced by receptor status.
I'm still on the fence about turmeric, although I suspect Kay's right about the caveats on WebMD being something of a blanket CYA statement...
Jan 11, 2015 08:34PM Hopeful82014 wrote:
Dear Kay - That's an excellent point - I'd been scanning through looking for references to HR status, etc., but it didn't occur to check for refs. to luminal status (slapping forehead). Thank you.
I think I'm going to research this a bit more but will not out and out avoid turmeric; it's possible role in inhibiting metastasis is certainly intriguing and I'd hate to miss out on that needlessly.
If anyone comes up with any further insights I'd love to hear about it.
Jan 11, 2015 09:21PM - edited Jan 11, 2015 09:23PM by granny72
I asked my MO about tumeric and she said to use it on eggs and salads.
We now put it in our salad dressing every day. My husband and l really like it.
Healing Spices by Bharat B Aggarwal talks about it and other spices to boost health and beat disease.
Jan 12, 2015 09:59AM carol57 wrote:
I emailed Dr. Aggarwal (I just googled to find his email address), asking him for his thoughts about the WebMD cautionary note. He replied, saying that there's evidence that curcumin exhibits anticancer activity against 'hormone-sensitive' cancers. Here is the list of studies he cited in his email:
1.Inhibitory effect of curcumin on uterine leiomyoma cell proliferation.
Tsuiji K, Takeda T, Li B, Wakabayashi A, Kondo A, Kimura T, Yaegashi N.Gynecol Endocrinol. 2011 Jul;27(7):512-7.
2.Why leiomyomas are called fibroids: the central role of extracellular matrix in symptomatic women.
Malik M, Norian J, McCarthy-Keith D, Britten J, Catherino WH.Semin Reprod Med. 2010 May;28(3):169-79. doi: 10.1055/s-0030-1251475. Epub 2010 Apr 22.
3.Curcumin, a nutritional supplement with antineoplastic activity, enhances leiomyoma cell apoptosis and decreases fibronectin expression.
Malik M, Mendoza M, Payson M, Catherino WH. Fertil Steril. 2009 May;91(5 Suppl):2177-84.
1.Curcumin inhibits endometriosis endometrial cells by reducing estradiol production.
Zhang Y, Cao H, Yu Z, Peng HY, Zhang CJ.Iran J Reprod Med. 2013 May;11(5):415-22.
2.Curcumin delays endometriosis development by inhibiting MMP-2 activity.
Jana S, Rudra DS, Paul S, Snehasikta S.Indian J Biochem Biophys. 2012 Oct;49(5):342-8.
3.Curcumin as anti-endometriotic agent: implication of MMP-3 and intrinsic apoptotic pathway.
Jana S, Paul S, Swarnakar S.
Biochem Pharmacol. 2012 Mar 15;83(6):797-804. doi: 10.1016/j.bcp.2011.12.030. Epub 2011 Dec 29.
4.Curcumin attenuates TNF-α-induced expression of intercellular adhesion molecule-1, vascular cell adhesion molecule-1 and proinflammatory cytokines in human endometriotic stromal cells.
Kim KH, Lee EN, Park JK, Lee JR, Kim JH, Choi HJ, Kim BS, Lee HW, Lee KS, Yoon S.
Phytother Res. 2012 Jul;26(7):1037-47. doi: 10.1002/ptr.3694. Epub 2011 Dec 20.
5.Inhibitory effect of curcumin on angiogenesis in ectopic endometrium of rats with experimental endometriosis.
Zhang Y, Cao H, Hu YY, Wang H, Zhang CJ.
Int J Mol Med. 2011 Jan;27(1):87-94. doi: 10.3892/ijmm.2010.552. Epub 2010 Nov 8.
6.Curcumin arrests endometriosis by downregulation of matrix metalloproteinase-9 activity.
Swarnakar S, Paul S.Indian J Biochem Biophys. 2009 Feb;46(1):59-65.
I have not attempted to find any of these--just got his email, and I'm traveling for work this week, so no time to work the Internet--but perhaps some of the amazingly savvy women here can check some of these studies out.
Jan 17, 2015 08:38PM MiracleMileM wrote:
I'm stage IV and with herceptin have been NED for 6-1/2 years. ER 85%, grade 3. Since 30-40% of those with stage IV HER2+++ end up with brain mets, I have been taking at least 4 grams of curcumin (and on an empty stomach 1.5 grams green tea extract wi quercetin) daily to damp down those brain met odds since both pass through the blood brain barrier and have anti-tumor effects. Herceptin does not pass through the blood-brain barrier. I think both also help with the arthritis & arimidex joint pain. I use Dr.'s best C-3 and phytosome. I'm sold on curcumin
Jan 21, 2015 04:14AM LindaKR wrote:
Wow, thank you all for all of the great research.
Jan 21, 2015 03:54PM Denise-G wrote:
Carol - thank you thank you thank you for this...I've been on the fence, and taking Turmeric here and there.
I just found this video as well - it doesn't address estrogen positive cancer though, but I liked the info:
Jan 22, 2015 10:08AM Dancermom1999 wrote:Ladies: I have been taking Turmeric supplements and just found this on the web. I am er+...uggg...
Curcumin is the therapeutic constituent of turmeric. Laboratory research has uncovered a potent phytoestrogen called diarylheptanoid in curcumin, according to Susan Lark, M.D. Phytoestrogens are plant chemicals that act like the hormone estrogen in the body. Lark writes that diarylheptanoid binds to estrogen receptors, causing advantages similar to estrogen. If you are experiencing symptoms such as vaginal dryness, curcumin may be of assistance.
Jan 22, 2015 10:53AM Hopeful82014 wrote:
Hi, Dancermom - That's my concern, too, about turmeric. I'd say if you're not ER+ then turmeric's a good thing. If you are, for me the jury's still out until I can obtain more information.
This doesn't mean I won't use is in cooking but I'm not going to supplement with it just yet.
Thanks for posting that quote, Dancermom. Can you provide a link to the source as well? (If not, I'll google it.)
Jan 22, 2015 01:39PM Dancermom1999 wrote:
Hopeful8201...here is the link...my onc said I could take it but now I am going to stop until I can speak to her. If you get more info please please post it.