I've been trying to find the answer to this via journal data, but no luck.
Inflammatory breast cancer is cited as "very rare" and that "1-5%" chance of IBC.
However, most women with IBC seem to be diagnosed once the IBC has caused the 'typical symptoms', many of these symptoms seem to imply that the BC had been in the breast causing "less obvious" symptoms for a while.
And, it sounds like many women struggle for months to get an answer for their symptoms before diagnosis.
So, given these pieces of information, my question is:
What population does the 1-5% statistic represent?
- Does it represent the population of "all people in the US with Breasts"? (ie: the total alive population; this seems unlikely)
- Or, does 1-5% mean "anyone who presents at any doctor with any breast symptom or concern to include the things women get brushed off for frequently before ultimate diagnosis: itchy breast, bug bite, allergy, eczema, psoriasis.
- Or, is it representing of all dx cancer cases? In this case, it is of "known cancers" which relies too much on the ability to diagnose this disease, which is foolish when this disease seems to be the hardest to diagnose early or accurately…which means that there's many women out there concerned with itchy breasts who should be included in that number but still need to struggle it out to get a dx. Doesn't seem like a good number that represents true frequency in a population.
To me, the second would be more informative, although much harder to track since women seem to see multiple providers over time to ultimately get a diagnosis and be believed (how would you create this dataset, aside from longitudinal self-report from women).
And, the second one would be more psychologically calming (because I noticed people cite the 1-5% all of the time, but 1-5% of all possible breast-havers is a big number and 1-5% of "known cancers" is not helpful).
It would also be interesting to see "accuracy by provider" stats (yes, I am dreaming here; we don't have a feedback loop like that in the US). Like baseball players, it would be helpful to know that a provider has a high batting average at identifying concerning symptoms early vs. waiting.
Maybe I'm thinking about this population data wrong, but I haven't seen citations for where the 1-5% number comes from.
Maybe women would be diagnosed earlier if there wasn't so much indexing going on of "1-5%"