TRIPLE POSITIVE GROUP
Comments
-
I had very intense tinnitus on the first tx - I had read that it was s sign of neurotoxic damage specifically from Carboplatin. It is nowhere as bad as it was, but is definitely still there. It varies in intensity - or I vary in how closely I am paying attention to it - not sure which! I plan to discuss this with my onc at the next appt in June. I am also going to ask if he has plans for my next echo - I had them quarterly, and one before and after Herceptin.
Stage IIb, Grade 3, 2/14 nodes, ER+/PR+, HER2+Surgery 11/01/2010 Mastectomy (Both); Reconstruction: Tissue expander placement (Both)Surgery 12/06/2010 Lymph Node Removal: Axillary Lymph Node Dissection (Right)Surgery 12/21/2010 Reconstruction (Left)Surgery 01/07/2011 Reconstruction (Left)Surgery 01/21/2011 Reconstruction (Left)Chemotherapy 02/17/2011 carboplatin, TaxotereTargeted Therapy 02/17/2011 HerceptinSurgery 07/20/2011 Reconstruction: Tissue expander placement (Left)Hormonal Therapy 08/01/2011 FemaraSurgery 02/24/2012 Reconstruction: Breast implants (permanent) (Both)Hormonal Therapy 06/20/2012 ArimidexSurgery 12/14/2012 Reconstruction (Both)
0 -
Grandma, I am having a lot of tinnitus as well. I guess it’s from the carbo. No one mentioned that to me either. It wouldn’t have made a difference but still.
I’m in that clinical trial and they ask me about all my SEs every so often. I continue to report the incessant nose running that we ALL know is from the herceptin. The study nurse has referred to it as allergies a few times. I do have allergies, but this isn’t allergies. This is incessant nose running from the herceptin. They don’t seem willing to acknowledge it as a SE. I mean it’s really minor but this is just to illustrate that if it’s not in the literature, they tend not to believe you, even if a whole bunch of us who are on the same drugs experience the same thing.
Generally my tinnitus hasn’t been very bad, but at one point during chemo, I think one of the earlier rounds but I don’t remember any more, I got up to go to the bathroom in the middle of the night and basically passed out. I saw it coming so I just laid down on the floor until I felt up to crawling back into bed. My ears were ringing really, really loudly, and no one has ever explained why that would be. For those of you who haven’t done chemo yet – there were a few times that were the worst for me and that was one of them. Generally it wasn’t *that* bad.
And also – you can keep your hair! There’s a cold caps thread. Dana, your hair looks very pretty – I kept most of mine thanks to the cold caps. There are lots of benefits of it, including a) I had a full head of hair at the end of chemo so I could feel “normal” again very quickly, and b) I’m very physically active and I never had to think, I don’t want to get on my bike because I don’t want my wig to fall off, or take that hike b/c it’s too hot to hike with the wig on, etc. Some ladies have a lot more courage and go commando but I have been very selective all along as to whom I told.
Here’s an example of why – I got my hair colored for the 1st time PFC a few weeks ago. My regular colorist, who knew about my DX, was out ill but gave the formula to the salon so they could color it. I told the hair dresser b/c it was relevant to how she treated my hair. I was there for two freaking hours and SHE JUST COULD NOT STOP talking about cancer!!! She was trying to be very sympathetic but honestly she killed a perfectly nice Saturday afternoon. Newsflash – talking about cancer is depressing, helloooo! Also hellooo, you’re not my friend! You’re just a woman I’ve never met before who is putting color in my hair! I eventually told her, firmly but as nicely as I could, that I did not want to talk about it any more. I literally will try to make my next appointment when she isn’t even in because I know she’ll look at me and think “cancer patient” for, like, ever.
0 -
I would be very interested in hearing a facility/MO recommendation from anyone in Rochester/Syracuse/Ogdensberg/Watertown NY area. If all goes according to plan my husband and I are hoping to salvage six weeks in SEPT/OCT at our summer cottage in Clayton NY (R&R from Texas heat!!! We are usually there June 1 to mid October so this BC summer really sucks big ones!!) I'll need at least two Herceptin treatments and would rather not just pick a site from phone book! THANKS for any recommendations.
Had my second TCH yesterday... not without a lesson in patience. MO forgot to write orders so I was two hours late getting started...I'd just seen her the day before...grrrrr. Didn't help the old blood pressure reading any!!! You can bet money that I'll be reminding her each visit from now on! Getting ready for oral steroids next few days and will be flying high...I'm a talker and this just ramps it up big time!
***So...has anyone else heard/read that minimal chemo gets past the "brain barrier" as my MO calls it? No warm fuzzies there...
Sending good thoughts to everyone for a GOOD week!0 -
Welcome to all the newbies, I read alot on this thread but don't post much, but I think u'll find it very interesting, loads of information and caring and u can always use that. Good Luck to all for a gentle healing.
0 -
GrandmaV - I am sorry that you are dealing with the annoying effects of tinnitus. It's hard to beleive that your MO has never heard of tinnitus from Carbo! That was one thing they always asked about everytime I went and decreased my dose twice because of it. I am sure there are other things that they should have told me but didn't, but that was one they were on top of.
I did find out from the BS yesterday that chemo kills off many of the lymphocytes and that is why they get far fewer nodes when they do surgery after chemo. Makes you wonder what lymphocyes are killed off in other parts of the body and what effects that has.
0 -
Bren I've always wondered wow Chemo is doing all this good. And what else is it hurtin, I mean cancer's pretty tough so why wouldn't other parts of healthy suff gett affected too. I honestly think the Drs. who even know the most are learning something new all the time and it changes every year, every patient, every day. We just do what we have to.???????
0 -
The role of androgen in many estrogen positive and her 2 pos breast cancers and the possibilty of a new line of hormonal therapy.....http://www.sciencecodex.com/aacr_news_studies_show_increasing_evidence_that_androgen_drives_breast_cancer-110144
0 -
I follow Dr Attai twitter and admire her enormously. this is precisely how progress is made ... MDS listening to their patients. By here...she is referring to her Facebook page......
Dr. Deanna J. Attai
8 hours ago ·
A bit of crowdsourcing help, please! I'm giving a talk at the upcoming The American Society of Breast Surgeons Annual Meeting - the tittle is: "Endocrine Therapy Side Effects and Treatment of Side Effects- What the Literature Says, What Your Patients are Saying"
Long title, I know! But I'm going to cover the reported side effects of tamoxifen and the aromatase inhibitors (arimidex, femara, and aromasin) and also what the literature reports as effective treatments.
Any physician treating patients with breast cancer knows that there are MANY side effects that get reported to us that we don't read about, and that there are many things patients find effective for managing those side effects that we don't have good evidence for.
Anyone comfortable with leaving your thoughts here, please do. No one will be mentioned by name or will be identified in any way - I'm interested in the side effects and remedies only. For those not comfortable leaving the information publicly, please email info@DrAttai.com - this email goes to me, not my staff, and as soon as I get the information I need, the emails will be deleted.
Thank you all in advance for your help! After the talk, I'll post the slides.0 -
Lago,
I remember you saying your Doc was on top of Herceptin research. I am sure she knows your case better than anyone else. And since you like her, and are comfortable with her, I am happy for you

Grandma,
Even my Cardiologist, (who wasn't versed in Herceptin initially) said a minimum of 5 years follow-up since I had damage during tx. He said this long before the latest study showing women suffering damage 5 years out was released last fall.
Here is my thinking on the whole "monitor the heart" since new info has become available. We know now, unequivocally that there are women who have no problems with Herceptin during treatment, were "released" with no follow up and have DIED because of damage in the 2-5 years following tx.
Some women don't die, but stumble along with a problem for years untreated. We also know *most* women have no SEs.
I don't think Oncs who omit monitoring the heart (with scans, how else can it be done?) are negligent.
Anymore.
I did for a long time.
I think they believe, despite the data, that "yeah, heart damage happens" and it might happen to one of their patients. But as of yet, there just isn't a whole lot they can do about it.
They prescribe meds designed for people who have heart issues not caused from chemo. So there doesn't seem to be any data that shows these drugs help with Herceptin damage.
So why worry the woman?
Especially since some women (those diagnosed with damage during tx or the first year after) often heal.
The jury is still out on women who get damage 4-5 years out. I don't think it's much of a logic jump to assume that won't heal itself in most cases. (Which also ties into what my Cardio and Onc told me. The chances of my heart healing go WAY down after the first 12 months off Herceptin. After that, while it can happen, it isn't *as* likely.)
In my head, lol, a lot of Oncs who don't monitor the heart despite the obvious and prolific data showing it can damage the heart years out...is much like their approach to the PR+ part of BC. Right now they are not convinced there is anything they can do about it for REAL (though there are theories the heart meds help, we can't be sure its the meds or the woman's body doing the healing).
What I don't like though is misinformation. The way I read Lago's Drs response (and I may have interpreted it wrong) is she denied the latest data.
There may not be anything that can be done about Herceptin heart damage, but we should not be misinformed on what IS known.
Having said all that. I'd still do Herceptin again. I do believe it is a miracle drug.
But when it's my time to die, I'd rather burn out (heart) than fade away (cancer)!
0 -
AA,
Thanks for that info. I don't think my Onc will prescribe it. But I will pick his brain and then ask my OB

I agree the whole vagina issue should be introduced at the very beginning. Sure there's nothing they can do about it...yet.
For me chemo didn't hurt my vagina. I started my periods again, and things were GOOD for the most part. Just a little lube and all was right with the world.
It wasn't until after my Ooph that things went from Good to "OMg, is this OVER YET?"
Which is sad on so many levels.
I am fortunate I've been married 25 years. Not because my husband needs sex less, but because sex was much more important the first couple decades to drawing us nearer to each other. It's a quandry. Men as a general rule, use sex to feel intimate and close....but how close can he feel when I'm holding my breath and trying not to scream? lol
Seems like, for now, this is one of those things in life I just have to carry.
I'll have to suck it up.
But knowing this burden was coming would have been NICE.
0 -
GrandmaV that's what I asked my onc… was issues after 5 years. As far as tinnitus your onc just wastn't telling you. Even I have read about this.
AA I think the doctors don't tell a lot because
A. we won't get all SE
B. they don't want to overwhelm us
C. some just forgetBut I do feel that the chemo binder I was given told me about a lot of things including the physical and emotional sexual dysfunction issues (2 pages devoted to it ). What my binder didn't go into was the nail issues. It only said "Rarely a patient may experience pain in the nail and loss of nails." I wasn't prepared for how much this SE sucks when you get it as bad as I did.
So my point is that some places do a better job than others educating their patients.
rivercottagegal if you are doing Herceptin only they can arrange for a nurse to come to you if your insurance covers it. I know someone who lived far from the treatment center did that for her remaining Herceptin after chemo. I think Carboplatin my cross the blood brain barrier. Thing is the brain is usually the last place cancer would show up. So for most of us it hasn't reached the brain and for many of us it hasn't even spread outside the breast but there is no way of knowing for sure.
0 -
rivercottage - here is a link to a thread of upstate New York peeps:
http://community.breastcancer.org/forum/5/topic/800306?page=1#post_3440725
tonlee - I share your situation, and am glad that this year will be our 30th anniversary. If this had happened earlier in our marriage things would probably not be so good, but I married a very patient man....
0 -
Sk,
We joke about all the prep work required now. The days of spontaneous combustion are gone.
0 -
ashla, Dr. Attai is wonderful. She is my second opinion breast surgeon and she is the ONLY reason I was able to get in with my oncologist - who has had a closed practice for years. I will be forever grateful to her and I'm thinking about having another consult with her regarding the results of an ultrasound of my axilla.
She also contacted several doctors about my micromet situation. She truly is one in a million!
0 -
Ashla - thanks for sharing - very interesting. I think I am going to have to get a twitter account.
Re: brain metastases - this is from the HER2support.org website, it was posted in 2010, I find it sobering if the information is accurate -
http://her2support.org/metastasis/brain-cns/
Edited to add link0 -
websister be warry of Dr. Google. That was true in 2010 but I believe a newer drug for triple positives (not sure if for Her2+ hormone negative) called Lapatinib can. Komen Linky to some information on drugs for Metastatic breast cancer treatments. But remember that 30% is of those who get metastatic disease. It is not talking about early stage, non mets cancer. But brain mets can be treated with radiation and surgery as well.
EDIT: I think Carboplatin also might cross the blood brain barrier too.
0 -
Websister and Lee A
I find twitter very difficult to Maneuver but love it for real time incoming info. Need a course on how to converse in Dr Attai's forums.
She is a remarkable women and seems to be an even more extraordinary MD/BS0 -
lago - I agree, some places do better than others. My initial discovery of the problems was long ago in comparison. However, I expected my Seattle cancer treatment center to do better by now than it has. I narrated somewhere on this site previously that 2 years ago I attended a "newbie" session presented at my cancer center by an oncology nurse, and made sure I was supportive in general of the nurse's presentation since the one other patient attending besides me was triple negative. I spoke afterward with the nurse about the un-forewarned issues post-chemo, and it was her position that such outcomes are rare....(!) The same response has been made to me by a physician who happens to be a no-chemo-recommended patient who has dealt with post-chemo patients. Are they in denial or am I, or are most women simply enduring it in silence (which doesn't allow any efforts toward solutions)? At any rate, the onc nurse recommended I make an appt for counseling at the cancer center psych office. I called and was told that they are unable to see patients who have no recurrence who are more than 2 years out from tx. A great way to limit complainers to those who have yet to get to the point where they realize how permanent these problems are. We do not exist.
Those who seem to be affected by these problems are not the younger patients (although part of the problem is that for us it seems to occur when we are doing quite well and not yet decrepit... mostly maybe those in their 50's at time of dx???)
I too am in a long relationship of 40 years duration... and my sweetie is also tolerant but we are both disappointed. I also find that with loss of libido it doesn't just affect sexuality. For me the loss of estrogen/libido has also reduced the enjoyment of other aspects of life in general. Drugs for this problem have not been helpful in the least. I do think it results in the need for some anger management that is self-destructive as well as somewhat annoying for others. Initially I thought perhaps adding more physical exercise would help to work some of that off, but after several months of that I felt worse and was dealing with additional physical damage to joints. I do think the existence of the problems need to be openly acknowledged so that it is more possible they might be addressed. In addition, it is true that the majority of bc patients are diagnosed over the age of 50, and although many of them fortunately are treated with the less-sexually damaging treatments, there still would be a rather large pile of us out there.
0 -
Lol Lago,
I used the Dr Google reference yesterday texting a gal pal....hahaha. So true.
0 -
In an effort to be transparent - the majority of my problems regarding the lack of libido/spontaneity/etc. stems less from chemo and more from hyst/ooph. My SE in this area long predated my BC diagnosis, but were instead side effects from that surgery and "surgical menopause" at the age of 45, which was 12 years ago.
0 -
ashla, the easiest way I've found to use/search/access Twitter is with Tweetdeck. I downloaded it a couple of years ago and I think it has since become an actual Twitter product.
I took a screenshot of it just now to give you an idea what it looks like.
I have several columns set up but for the sake of not messing up the page width here at BCO.org I've included just two columns in the screenshot. I have one column set up for Dr. Attai's tweets and that makes it easier to follow the Monday night breast cancer social media (#BCSM) chats.
0 -
Lago - I actually used the 'beware Dr. Google' admonition on another thread here fairly recently myself
. I belong to the HER2 forum that I provided the link from and my background is in nursing. I will be careful 
LeeA - thanks for the info on tweet deck
0 -
Thx much Lee..very helpful!
0 -
GrandmaV -Sorry to hear you are still suffering from the tinnitus. I still have it, but it has diminished in intensity. I have learned to block it out, for the most part (except when I think about it, like now, LOL). I sure do hope you can train your brain to block it out better. It's probably much louder than mine, which would be difficult indeed to ignore.

TonLee - regarding not being able to build muscle mass...I have become prediabetic due to the high dose steroids I received during chemo last year. My onc thought I would recover, and it would go away, but no such luck. I am reading a book about diabetes, and it talks about how those who have insulin resistance have more difficulty building muscle mass. So, just a thought - have you had your a1c checked? All of my regular glucose screenings have been normal, but my a1c showed me as prediabetic. I have no symptoms (except some mild thrush still continues 1 year post chemo, most likely due to my elevated sugar levels). So it is quite possible to be prediabetic and have no clue. I am checking my glucose now after meals and learning exactly what spikes my sugar levels. It's an eye opener. I can't even have healthy carbs. Steel cut oatmeal spikes me way up into the abnormal range.
If I can't get it under control with diet I will be considering Metformin, especially since cancer recurrence risk is elevated for those with diabetes.
0 -
Wow Dance,
I am so sorry about that...I see an Endo every 6 months, he does a whole thyroid panel, cholesterol, and triglycerides. I will ask him about that though the next time I see him.
Thanks
0 -
lago, SpecialK and anyone else who has had ALND surgery, please tell me what to expect in the way of pain and recovery. BS says I will be in the hospital overnight, have drains for 10 days or until output is less than 30cc per day and be able to go back to work in 2 weeks. Both my mom and my daughter want to come and take care of me, but before I call in the cavalry I want to make sure it is really warranted. I tend to be an independant person and am not sure I can handle all the mothering, but I remember after the BMX I could hardly do anything for the first week. DH will be here to help and he is great with cleaning, laundry etc. Not so much on the cooking though.
0 -
Bren I also had nodes on the right (4 nodes) so some things like opening the fridge door (used my foot) and getting up from bed (thank goodness I was in great shape with strong abs) were not something my arms could assist. Stripping my drains myself was impossible with both sides having node surgery. But I managed most other things.
Be sure to put things low enough to reach (think bathroom). When you have drains you are not supposed to let your upper arms go above your shoulders… but it hurts to much to do that anyway for the first week or so.
You might need help washing your hair. I went to the hair dresser for that. You will need help handling anything heavy like laundry, vacuuming etc. My sister came to help but I really didn't need her other than to drive. You are allowed to drive if you are not on narcotics. I decided I would not drive till I could put my arm over the back seat and look behind me. Not a real problem for me because I live in the city and can take public transportation (or taxi).
I ended up kicking my sister out 1 week post BMX, 4-5 days after she got there. Long story but she was more of a hassle than help. The first few days at home I needed some assistance but my husband took the week of my BMX off. I had it on a Tuesday night. You'll find you'll be pretty tired. Your body is healing and that takes up a lot of energy.
I'm not a good person to ask about pain. I found out that I have a pretty high tolerance. I never took any narcotics, never used the pain pump, not even a Tylenol. The nice thing about surgery is every day you feel so much better that for me it wasn't all that bad.
0 -
Lago -Good info about nurse possibly coming to me for the Herceptin...thanks..I will look into that. Also thanks for brain info...not looking to borrow trouble but that seems to be the ONLY part of my body they didn't run on me so my mind is running amok! ;-)
0 -
bren - I had a kind of similar situation to you in that I had a double SNB with my BMX but had the ALND later. Mine was done as an outpatient surgery. You are not having any other surgery with this, correct? Is this your dominant hand side? When I had the node surgery five weeks after BMX (on the right side) I had recovered to a certain degree from the BMX to be able to use my left arm for some things, but I am right-handed so motor skills with the left hand for some things was a challenge - like say...eyeliner, lol! I was not yet driving from the BMX, so that went out the window again. My drain was not in long - I don't seem to have much trouble with drains and they usually come out in a week - I have had them three times and was the same each time. My DH handled the drains for a few days, but I could do it by myself for the next few until removal. I will give you a warning that I wish I had been given - take a Xanax or an Ativan if you have one lying around before you have that drain pulled - it felt like I had been shocked with a cattle prod. I am not trying to scare you, I am telling you this honestly so you are prepared. I hope that I am the exception to the rule and that your drain removal is a breeze, but I would pre-medicate and have someone drive you. All during treatment I did not take either of those drugs, but if I had to do it again I would have taken something first. I was fine later in the day so it was not a long lasting issue, just a surprise. I had four drains with BMX and it smarted a bit when they were removed, but because of the nature of ALND surgery this was a different type of feeling. I really didn't reach up with my arm for a couple of weeks - I kept it close to my side when walking around. I did not take much in the way of pain meds - only at night to help with sleep, and only probably for the first 2-3 nights. The feeling I had was not really painful, it was more a kind of tingling and numbness, which gradually subsided. I have full feeling in my arm, the only permanently numb place is my underarm but I only notice that when I shave - I get a weird zinger on my shoulder blade. The recovery of feeling in my bicep area took a while, so don't panic if it takes a while. I had some challenges with doing things - I had been using my left arm for things, but 2 weeks after the ALND surgery I had an emergency surgery on the left side because my TE ruptured through the skin on the face of the breast. Had the TE removed and replaced and the skin excised and restitched. At that point I was out of arms to use! I would advise to get all caught up on household stuff, maybe make some dinners ahead and freeze so DH can microwave or put something in the oven. I did not have any help other than DH and DD (she was 21 at the time and lived at home, but was working and going to college) here and there. DH washed my hair for me, and carried anything that was too heavy, but he just took off work for a few days - that was all that was needed.
0 -
I started tamoxifen on April 1, and so far so good - well, until tonight when I had my first side effect. I had charlie horses in both calves (not at the same time, thankfully). My MO listed that as a possible side effect, but he didn't explain WHY tamoxifen causes Charlie horses. Anyone know the mechanism? Maybe if I know what is causing it to happen I can do something to prevent them in the future?
0