Best Of
Re: Looking for others with low risk, less than 2cm, IDC stage 1 grade 1HR+ HER2- on endocrine therapy
Hello, all who are here or find this thread! Thank you for adding your stories, information, and experiences to this thread. This is, Pam/livinglifenow, an absurd disease. I am both so matter-of-fact about it and terrified of living with it for the rest of my life I alternately laugh and cry! And I am constantly in awe of all that my fellow humans here have endured and continue to endure in the name of treatment.
Some good news: my first annual mammogram and ultrasound was clear.
Some mediocre news: At 49 I already have osteopenia, as found by a DEXA scan (bone density test) on the same day of my mammogram. Osteopenia is low bone density, and my latest oncologist suspects it is hereditary. Mine is not severe or even considered something to treat if it was my only health issue. Just up my calcium and vitamin D intake. Of note, my mother has been on EVISTA since her early menopause at 40, and this SERM, originally designed to help fight breast cancer (it didn’t), strengthens bones. So I will never know what my mother’s bones were like at my age, but I do know my maternal grandmother and paternal grandmother did not have osteoperosis. Only 10% of us diagnosed with osteopenia will develop osteoperosis. But it is important to know about before you start aromatase inhibitors. Where Tamoxifen builds bones, aromatase inhibitors can deplete them. This has been on my mind!
I am fresh from my appointment with the specialist at Fred Hutch in Seattle. I was hoping with my low (but not ultra-low), recurrence rate risk she would look at my poor tolerance of tamoxifen and tell me further forays into endocrine therapy were entirely optional. Alas, she did quite the opposite. She printed out a New England Journal of Medicine article from 2017 showing that, in broad terms, my tumor characteristic risks were about a 14% 20 year recurrence rate with 5 years of endocrine therapy, roughly 28 without. I did note that this paper is alomst 10 years old, but it is unlikely all that much has changed. These numbers are generalized, of course, but the mammaprint (which gave me 98% metastasis free at 5 years with 5 years of endocrine therapy) and the Oncotype tests (4% 5 year distant recurrence risk, which lines up with the mammaprint pretty squarely) genetic tests don’t look very far into the future. Diagnosed at 49, I am still considered “young” for this disease, so we are looking at hopefully another 40-50 years of disease-free existence. Hooray for medicine, but also, I was brought to tears at the idea of trying endocrine therapy a second time. I fought hating Tamoxifen, but taking a holiday from it showed me just how negatively impactful the side effects were. I do not think I could go back on it and endure with any joy in my life.
The new doctor’s prescription is exemasthane (Aromasin), which is the one steroidal aromatase inhibitor (AI) among the three common AIs. It is considered the nicest one for side effects, especially hot flashes. She is choosing it because hot flashes were my primary complaint with Tamoxifen. Along with this, after 3 months or so, she plans on administering bisphosphonates via IV, roughly with a plan for 6 infusions over 3 years. These help strengthen bones and the medication in particular makes bones unattractive for cancer cells to grow in. I’m not sure we know why. Side effects include feeling flu-like for a few days, so not as awful as daily AIs, but there is a tiny weird chance to develop bone death in the jaw if you need dental surgery in the future. I have good teeth, but be sure to ask your docs about this strange side effect. It is rare and can be cured, but it doesn’t sound pleasant, and mostly affects people who need to have teeth extractions or implants.
A hot flash and menopause note: due to covid, I skipped an obgyn checkup with the obgyn’s consent. I had no concerns and good health. I think I was seeing her every other year. She never told me to note my last menses, and I was lax about it, as I wasn’t very worried about pregnancy for my own reasons. When I was diagnosed with breast cancer, docs naturally asked when my last cycle was and the male doctors I was predominantly seeing essentially gaslit me into thinking I was still perimenopausal. In hindsight, I was most definitely post menopause by March, 2024 (defined as one year past my final cycle).
I never had any menopause indications except a few heavier periods in perimenopause. Not. One. Hot. Flash. Nothing! Just a cessation of menstruation. So the endocrine issues of body temperature regulation I experienced were entirely due to Tamoxifen. Going off the drug in the last month has confirmed that Tamoxifen alone was to blame for my continuous discomfort. That said, with the new prescription, I may also start accupuncture, which is proven to help with hot flashes without side effects. There is an accupuncturist near where I live, but there is also an option to commute into Seattle (an hour and a half plus a ferry ride) to get specialist acupuncture treatments. If it works for me, fantastic! It takes a few weeks of weekly treatments to kick in, and then needs to be maintained weekly. The rub is that insurance may or may not cover it, and if it does cover it, it may only be 10-12 appointments in one calendar year. Wouldn’t you just like to put insurance companies in a dunk tank and throw balls at the dunk target all day long?
I am once again a prisoner of hope going into this new type of medication. One med at a time, the new doc says! So I will start exemasthane, insurance willing, in a week or so. I am trying not to feel wry that this diagnosis was my birthday gift last year and this year it is a new suite of endocrine-crushing medications. Sometimes it is hard to see that these are gifts! If I had not been diagnosed, 53 might have been my final birthday. Fifty is coming up in a few days. I am happy to be here and be cancer-free, but I don’t wish this ongoing preventive medicine and scans, tests, squeezes, and blood draws on anyone. :(
To be clear and up front, it wasn’t just the hot flashes I couldn’t tolerate with Tamoxifen. I was having them at a rate of 24+ a day. The dry skin on my back in particular was intense and became acne and is still healing! So wildly itchy!! My scalp went off the rails with sebbhoric dermatitis that stung and crusted and ached and made me feel like an embarrassed, awkward teen. I developed nerve twinges in my back and left hand that I had never had before and couldn’t attribute to anything else. My hands and feet were constantly throbbing with heat or frozen blocks. I sunburnt in under 3 minutes. There was ALOT going on. Insomnia and brain fog were also part of the picture. My body clearly was rejecting any amount of the medication, and I did try doses 10 mg and below in all sorts of comnbinations and times of day. How I envy those of you this drug worked for.
On this brief one-month endocrine therapy holiday, I felt like myself again for the first time since I began the drugs in January. To curl up with a blanket or start a conversation (one of my reliable triggers) without a hot flash has been exquisite.
The new doc did acknowledge that with my suite of side effects on Tamoxifen, no amount of good eating, exercise, or meditation would have helped me overcome the things I was experiencing. It is a good thing to know when you have had enough. My side effects were definitely in the unusual and extreme camp. If you have not started the drug and are afraid, just be vigilant and learn as much as you can. And trust yourself. Most of us will not have these side effects.
Now I am rooting for exemesthane and bisphosphonates. I know the AI drugs are superior to Tamoxifen in cancer-fighting power, and the bisphosphonates, which no one had ever offered me previously, will help my bones and at least offer me something I can do even if I end up not being able to tolerate the AIs.
Pam/Livinglifenow, we see you and want you to know we are here for you! Your story gives me a little more strength to dive into this next stab at reducing my risk. Remember, everyone, that we are all individuals. Most breast cancers do not recurr. But some do, no matter how good we are at following all the best advice.The more you know, the more these diagnoses are like crossing a busy highway. There are hazards, but we can avoid most of them, or at least help each other see the oncoming hazards. When you don’t educate yourself, or don’t reach out to others, it is more like swimming across a muddy river full of crocodiles. Learn, connect. Hope, vent. Begin again.
Pam, Keep us up on your progress when you have the energy. We are thinking of you! I will let you all know how the new meds fare in my system.
Re: thread for middle age to older Christian women.
Chris, I hope a new pillow will solve your headache problems. I do pray that your GERD related to your new med will have a solution when you see your pcp next week. I hope you get to enjoy your new strawberry dessert tonight and have some nice relaxing time on your deck.
Thank you for asking about Cammie. Here is a recent picture from last week when we came home from the vet. Her beautiful blue eyes you can't see as her eyes still looked wild from the anesthesia. They had to shave off many mats and her poor litttle chest got shaved a lot. This has been a very tough last week. I have been on an emotional roller coaster with a glimmer of hope to the opposite. I messaged the vet's office yesterday as Cammie developed awful liquid diarrhea and I thought it was the increased steroid she is one as her new protocol. The vet said it was not the meds but her pancreas. I didn't know what that meant but it made me see that she may be in pain and I didn't know it. I made the tough decision today that I will have her put down tomorrow at 1pm. I hate it that my vet will not be there as she is so good and spent so much time with me last Tues. discussing options. I am really struggling with this knowing everything today will be her last. She is still in her diehard routine as if everything is normal. I got up very early today and couldn't sleep as I was messaging my vet. So I went downstairs and Cammie came down and laid on my lap for a while but she knew this wasn't her normal routine so she is now sleeping in my bedroom. We will have some time tonight before the dreaded day. Her hind legs were so hard for her to maneuver once she got on my lap and I just couldn't see her dealing with that anymore. Trying to choose the end of her life day was pretty surreal. I would have probably waited until Thursday but my Bible study teacher invited me and two others from our Bible study to help her celebrate her Mom's 95 birthday at a fancy restaurant on Saturday and I didn't want to be a total basket case for this. Her Mom is a pistol. For her 90th birthday she sky dived!!!! Makes my balloon ride at 50 look a little tame. LOL I would appreciate your prayers. I really didn't anticipate this being as hard as it is. She is my family and we have an unusually close bond. God gave me a gift with her even though in her initial kitten stage I was so upset not knowing how to deal with her back then it would have been hard for me to imagine how close we would become. There are many life lessons in this long 17 yr journey of how God can turn something we think is a challenge into a blessing. So this will be my last picture of her. Thank you all for your prayers for her. She made it to 17 yrs and 3 mos. I will miss her terribly.
Love,
Nancy
Re: Can we have a forum for "older" people with bc?
One of the things that really helped me cut down on sodium was switching away from table salt to "kosher" salt (Diamond Crystal) like chefs use—flaky, larger surface area so you use less. No iodine, but we eat a lot of fish anyway (and snack on nori). I salt from way up high so it falls evenly; and if I salt anything after cooking I use Maldon flake salt or French "fleur de sel." Again, just a little goes a long way. I use kosher salt for pasta water (in a "Fasta Pasta" microwave cooker that uses much less water and is really fast) even though it's more expensive than table salt. But what really changed the game for me was when a client paid me for defending her traffic ticket with a huge gift box assortment from Penzey's. I love using herbs (fresh when in season), spices, extracts, oils and vinegars (especially the little bottle of 25-yr-old Aceto Balsamico "Tradizionale" I dole out in drops over strawberries and insalata Caprese).
Hit the farmer's market today—jackpot! Tart cherries, raspberries & blueberries from MI; strawberries, heirloom tomato, bell pepper from IL; and a sourdough from a local bakery. The empanada lady was sold out; I still have lots of coffee beans and haven't scooped any of the rhubarb sorbet so I skipped those stands as well as the Greek olive oil guys (I have a full set of Graza olive oils from Spain: Drizzle as a condiment, Sizzle for light sauteeing, Frizzle for higher heat—I use that instead of butter for fried eggs). And noticed that back at the house, some of our black raspberries are ripening!
Messaged the derm last night about the cyst, and her nurse called this morning to get me in today. Turns out she's not going to excise the cyst just yet—the plan is to calm it down and shrink it. So she switched me to a different antibiotic that has a little anti-inflammatory action, and injected a little steroid into the reddest part. Wouldn't you know it that tonight I happened to tune into "Dr. Pimple Popper" and the blobs-du-jour were epidermoid cysts! I now know more than I ever wanted to know about them (including what they look like beneath the skin, eeeuuwww).
We went to the wake for Bob's nurse's 22-yr-old son who was shot point-blank in the head. Turns out it was retaliation for dropping out of his gang. The funeral home was packed, and there were guards and police galore. Will be missing the funeral tomorrow (in our old neighborhood, Andersonville, where we lived before buying our house) because Bob has to work and I never met anyone there. Afterward, we went out for tapas. For dessert, I'd been jonesing for Oberweis' black forest chip ice cream, but when we got there it was out of season. Normally, I'd have chosen another flavor, but thanks to Zepbound I was able to turn around and go home. (I did indulge in some "Rebel" keto triple chocolate from the freezer—which we've started to clear out).
We were able to get a 1-month lease extension on the rental house—but from the landlord's housing agency, not State Farm which refuses to cover any more rent. I'm seething: swung by the house to get mail today and found nothing's been done in over a week. No way in hell could we have moved back in today—we'll be lucky to do so by 7/15, when our new bed will be delivered. I don't know who to be angrier at: the State Farm adjuster who suddenly decided to cheap out on us, or the contractor—who is directly responsible for costing us an extra $8500 (July's "rack rate" rent). I got the reconstruction check today, but am not endorsing any of it over till we are satisfied. Tomorrow they'll be doing the exterior painting on the rear wall (window frames & shingles), which is an "extra." (I paid, but according to the specs it was supposedly included, and the summary list said it was supposedly completed and billed to State Farm). Meanwhile, can't have the fridge moved back till we get the water line…which they can't do because they're busy painting (and having to remove much of the ivy to do it). Tomorrow I finish measuring the windows, take delivery of Bob's new radio/CD changer, and weed out the pile of junk on the master BR floor. Will postpone the window-treatments appointment till next week. Still have to order twin mattresses and at least 2 sets of linens for each bed—will see how much was salvaged by the textile-cleaners. Somewhere in that pile are a bunch of curtain rods and shades (though the latter are 40 years old and in rough shape). Will also call RCN to resume internet & cable (but not landlines)—can't make an appointment till we get the hardware & its furniture back from storage. On the fence about resuming satellite DirecTV, because we've gotten used to streaming it here, which avoids "storm fade" because the dish is not part of the system. Of course, we need to shop for a new TV and two large enough stands to accommodate it and the other one we're moving up front.
Probably have BFFs over to grill on the 4th—one last hurrah with the Weber kettle (unless there's a "no open flames" advisory, in which case we'll use the panini press instead). Not going to Skokie see the fireworks—we'll just watch them (DC, NYC) on TV. Will be too hot to spend much time outdoors.
Re: Signatera test -pros cons
@kotchaj I agree with you regarding that the Signatera test is only looking for the characteristics of the tumor that was biopsied. For example, when I was diagnosed with Stage 1 BC 16 years ago, the Signatera test did not exist. However, even if I were to have used it in recent years, with my 16 year-old tumor characteristics (prior to my MBC diagnosis in 2024), would the test have found anything, since my new MBC tumor has different characteristics? Hard to know.
I now have had the Signatera test done several times, following my initial MBC treatment. As you can see by my signature, the first time it was negative. I went on a short treatment holiday and 6 weeks later the test showed extremely low positive. A month later I had a PET which showed slight uptake in an area that had previously had some uptake that had gone away. So, we started treatment again. If the PET had shown nothing (with a negative Signatera), I imagine the next step would have been a brain scan. If that had shown nothing, I'm not sure what my MO would've suggested.
I am having a Brain MRI, PET/CT and Signatera test—all in July. Just standard of care tests at this point. Hoping for good results given my current course of treatment. Wish there was a simple finger-prick blood test for all of this instead!
Hugs to all, Pam 💗
Re: Birads 5 with calcification
@scaredme Thank you so much for giving me a sense of hope. Right now, I’m just praying that it’s somewhere between stages 1 and 3. I honestly don’t know how I’d handle a stage 4 diagnosis. I’ve been experiencing so many different symptoms, and it’s hard not to fear the worst. It feels like every other day brings something new that sends me into a full-blown panic. Lately, I’ve had leg cramps that started with my period, and I can’t help but worry about the possibility of bone metastases. I’m really hoping for answers soon (and good ones) before the stress completely overwhelms me.
Re: Starting Chemo June 2025? Let's support each other here!
@iambecoming Yes, I start the day before you do on 6/30! I feel the same way. I am nervous and excited at the same time. My last first chemo session, ya know? Sleeping has become a little bit more difficult with the anxiety ramping up for sure. But trying to just work out as much as I can to deal with it and get strong for Monday. We got this!
Re: Not Diagnosed and Waiting for Test Results? Start Here
Hi all, I am a 42 year old woman waiting for my biopsy results for architecture distortion of 7mm and another region close to this is an asymmetry. Given the two findings, I’m hoping to see some good results. The technician told me that worst case, the size of suspicious regions are small, and not spread to lymph nodes. So I could just remove them. I liked how she was trying to sound assuring, however I don’t know how much of a process it is to remove it. I guess there’s a lot of protocol to follow after that too.
I don’t see a lot of posts on architecture distortion. Makes me scared even more
Oh well, as someone said on this thread, I feel like breaking the clock since it has stopped working!



