I'm starting this thread because I thought it might be useful for those of us undergoing this procedure. (I surely can't be the only one that did it!) I did find a thread that was a couple of years old, but it really didn't address what I hope to here, which is a description of the process, experiences of the procedure, and what to expect afterwards. While I've gotten some good information from the lumpectomy threads and some from the reconstruction threads, hopefully this is a way to put it all together. What follows is a combination of what I've experienced and what I've read about oncoplasty as I researched it pre-op. Hope it helps.
What is it?
Essentially, it's a lumpectomy combined with a bilateral reduction mammaplasty (bilateral lift and reduction)
Why do it?
Margins: This technique allows the surgeon to get large margins without fear of leaving the breast deformed or having the two breasts be lopsided after surgery. Good margins, as many of us know, are critical. My tumor was fairly shallow, so that is my closest margin, the one to the skin, and that one is 6mm. The rest are 14mm +. My
lumpectomy specimen, as delivered to pathology, was 7 cm x 7 cm x 4 cm for a 1.7 cm tumor, so pretty large. In addition to that even more tissue was removed from my breast(s) by the plastic surgeon. If future breastfeeding isn't a concern, they try to remove a lot of the parenchymal tissue from both breasts (the ducts and lobules) so theoretically that might also reduce some recurrences (studies still underway).
Radiation: From what my Dr. said and from what I've read, oncoplasty actually makes it easier for the follow-up radiation, which is an essential part of the treatment plan for oncoplastic lumpectomy, just like with regular lumpectomy. Easier positioning, easier to accurately dose, fewer complications.
Edited to add follow-up 6 months after radiation: Radiation was very easy for me with no skin breakdown or major problems. I have no idea if the reduction surgery helped in that regard or if it would have been that way anyway, but just weighing in on my experience.
Tumor location: Sometimes a tumor is located in a position that will make it more difficult for a breast surgeon to remove it all with good margins and still leave the breast looking fairly normal. In my case, my tumor was situated at about the 11:30 position, but much of it was actually under the areola-nipple complex. My surgical breast oncologist immediately offered this procedure to me as the way to get the best oncological and cosmetic results from the surgery. It can also be used to allow the lumpectomy option for some women who might have tumors larger than what is usually considered optimal for breast conserving surgery.
Physical/cosmetic: First, I should say that cosmetic results were almost the last thing on my mind when I started to go through this a couple of months ago. Having said that, I'm very satisfied with what my breasts look like/feel like now compared to my "BC" (Before Cancer) days. Not something I could have predicted as an outcome. While only a size D "BC," my breasts were uncomfortable -- saggy (ptosis), heavy (bra-strap indentations), cumbersome. I never would have sought out any surgery like a lift and reduction, but now having had it I just feel much better, aside from the post-surgical pain. The main reason for doing it, for me, was not the cosmetics but for the oncological benefits...however, if I have to go through having cancer, it's a nice, unexpected consolation prize. Some plastic surgeons will only do one breast initially and then do the other after radiation is completed and they can match it up better to the treated breast. The other option, which mine did, was to do them both at once and leave the cancerous breast slightly larger, anticipating it'll shrink down a little bit after radiation, with the plan of evening them out later only if necessary.
Edited to add follow-up 6 months after radiation: My PS's calculations were pretty correct and the radiated breast has shrunk down a little bit so they're pretty close to equal. It's still a tiny bit bigger, but I still feel occasional tightening going on so wouldn't be surprised if it shrinks down a tiny bit more. I'm pretty happy with the result. The scars have also faded considerably and I suspect that eventually they'll barely be noticeable.
Contraindications: Multi-focal cancers, certain kinds of aggressive cancers, any condition that would make a MX the best treatment of choice, not having access to an experienced team to perform the surgery (SO/BS + PS), small breasts. And probably more that I haven't run across yet.
Complications/negatives: Like with any surgery, they happen. Sometimes margins are still compromised. Sometimes there are issues with healing. Sometimes there is a loss of sensation in parts of the breast (more on that in next post). Sometimes there is a loss of the ability to breastfeed. There is a longer recovery time as compared to regular lumpectomy.
The next post will just focus on what I've learned in terms of preparation for surgery and recovering from the surgery, in case it might help someone else.
There's a lot of information about oncoplasty online, but here are a couple of sites that seem credible that I've run across.
http://www.hindawi.com/journals/ijso/2012/907576/#...
http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC288471...