I'll try to keep the background as short as possible—unfortunately, it is a bit of a twisted tale.
I had a screening breast MRI in Sept. last year. It came back BI-RADS 5 (greater than 95% likely cancer). The targeted US showed a rather benign-looking nodule that was presumed to be the one seen on the MRI. An US-guided biopsy was finally done in late Nov. and it came back benign (fibroepithelial, likely fibroadenoma).
The pathology requisition noted as clinical context: "a benign-appearing 1.3 cm lesion". This information is supposed to inform the radiologist of the reason for the pathology. In hindsight, I wonder if this may have affected how thorough the pathology was conducted since the US didn't show anything suspicious. The pathology requistion failed to note the BI-RADS 5 MRI, my high risk family history of breast and ovarian cancer, or my extremely dense breasts which increases my risk of cancer. A follow-up MRI was done to check the clip placement 6 months later and the clip was adjacent to the nodule. It was not within the MRI identified nodule. The radiologist interpreting the second MRI failed to mention the spiculation noted in the first MRI and only said the lesion was unchanged. He went on to say the MRI result would be compatible with a fibroadenoma. He didn't provide a BI-RADS designation or explain the apparent downgrading of the lesion.
My GP is happy with the benign diagnosis. I'm not quite ready to settle for a fibroadenoma diagnosis just yet. I believe there have been missed steps. A radiology-pathology correlation (rad-path) was never done to reconcile the discordant benign pathology with the BI-RADS 5 MRI. The clip wasn't placed within the lesion so adequate targeting and sampling can't be confirmed. My GP declined to order a radiology-pathology correlation but did refer me to an oncology surgeon for a second opinion.
The oncology surgeon was satisfied with the fibroadenoma diagnosis yet understood how I might be worried due the BI-RADS 5 result and my high risk family history. She agreed to do a lumpectomy to reassure me. It was supposed to be sometime in September. I wanted to ask my surgeon whether the pathology would be 'standard' or more attuned with what would be done for a patient with a BI-RADS 5, high risk family and missing rad-path. Well, I got the call late last week that the surgery will be next Monday, and my surgeon is currently out of the country and won't be back to meet with prior to Monday's surgery. I checked with the MOA and she said the consult confirms the lumpectomy will be done for 'reassurance' and not to resolve the significant risk of upgrade to malignancy. I'm a retired RN with 28 years in acute care hospital. I've done the research and I know my concerns are well founded. Standard care for a MRI BI-RADS 5 with a discordant benign pathology is excision. Unfortunately, I feel like my concerns are being brushed off as an "anxious woman".
If the surgery is elective and for reassurance only, then the pathology that will be done will be routine and consist of a few slices and not a thorough histopathological assessment of the whole nodule. The MOA told me I can speak with the surgeon right before the surgery or I can cancel and reschedule. I don't want to reschedule—it's been 11 months that I've been dealing with this and waiting for resolution. I want to speak with the surgeon and make it clear I need a full histopathological assessment and assurance that my high risk family hx, extremely dense breasts and MRI BI-RADS information be listed on the pathology requisition. I want to ask for a radiology-pathology correlation. I asked my sister who is an RN too but works in the community, about this and she feels that I probably won't get the result I'm looking for. That it might negatively impact my relationship with the surgeon. She thinks I should just let my surgeon 'do her thing'—that surgeon knows what she's doing.
I'm sorry for the length of this. Apologies to those who have stuck along this far. For context: I live in British Columbia, Canada, in a mid-size city in the interior of BC and not Vancouver. Second opinions are pretty much non-existent and patients are limited in their say regarding their care. So, do I let the surgeon know how I feel and what I need to feel confident in the final diagnosis or should I just assume my surgeon knows what she's doing and drop it???
Opinions, please and thank-you. ☺️
Barbara