Just trying to find out if the following:
(People with hisk oncodx and no chemo)
Oncodx number
Number of years NED
No chemo but did 4 years AI.
Oncodx 34
NED 5 years.
For people high oncodx and chose no chemo
How long NED
testing
ok here is my post
following
34, year 10 ned
Yay!! to 10 years NED. Nice to see you back Meow13!
hello meow 13!!
What a strange year or so we’ve had! UK kind of opened up a bit now but who knows!?
Fantastic - 10 years!! Excellent
Anyway as you might recall I was in a state about having chemo as I’d been told I didn’t need it until my onco score of 30. I didn’t do it and it’s 2 and a half years out and ok. I’m thinking of coming off the hormone therapy as tamoxifen has caused thickening in womb lining and letrozole looks punishing!
It’s now clear that even with an oncotype score like that the latest studies show having chemo makes no difference and so we were right to question!
I hope you are doing ok and sending very best wishes to you across the pond!!! You were such a help to me will always be grateful…
two and a half years:)
I had an onco score of 44 and did chemo and 8 months into tamoxifen. I also do herbs from George Wong. My oncologist started me on 20mg, but I recently went down to 15 and am considering going down further to 10mg as I am really struggling, mentally and physically.
10 years NED, fabulous! Following..
34, on 11th year NED
I would love to know also how many people who chose no chemo with a high onco score and how they are doing now. I have a score of 26 and I am choosing no chemo. ER/PR+, her2- Stage 1, 1.5 cm, grade 3 tumor. I start radiation next Wednesday.
update: 10 months out, mammo and lung scan both clear. I chose no chemo. I have been on letrozole since August and did a month of radiation.
I chose no chemo. Felt obvious not to do it after much research. Onco score of 30. Estrogen positive. Stage1/2 grade 2
5 years now ok.
still anxious ! Good luck
sissy60
Also a friend of mine just had a recurrence after 7 years - and her onco score was 8. She was led to assume she’d be fine. Oncotype isn’t definitive is it?
Jenna, the current research still shows tremendous benefit for those with a high oncotype score. Breast cancer, before even being able to be detected by scan or touch, tend to shed through surrounding blood vessels. The more aggressive the tumor which is defined by a high oncotype, the more likely that is to have happened. Chemo goes after those errant cells killing them before they have a chance to attach to a distant organ and grow. Because at that point the cancer is no longer curable. It is up to you to decide whether the risks of chemo outweigh the rewards but your oncologist gave you an accurate assessment. There is no guarantee either way of course but those who have chemo if needed, statistically speaking do much better than those who don't.
I see lots of people with low oncoscores having recurrences as well as people who did aggressive chemo regimens. And then I see women with high oncoscores who chose no chemo who are still years out without a recurrence. I guess there's just no guarantees when it comes to cancer.
No there are no guarantees unfortunately. Just statistics that suggest what would be most beneficial. I had no lymph node involvement or LVI and an intermediate onco score that because I was under 50 suggested chemo was beneficial. I did it. It wasn't fun but I got through it and recovered fully. And I know if I had a recurrence I'd have no regrets. I think that's an important thing.
"The surgeon told me that in premenopausal women they aren't sure if the benefits of chemo are due to the damage to the ovaries or the actual chemo."
I thought I should mention that this only applies to women whose oncotype score is between 21 to 25. For premenopausal women who score over a 25, chemo is always beneficial not because it affects the ovaries but because it kills aggressive breast cancer cells. I had a 23 score and still chose chemo though. I wanted to take as few chances as possible.
Thank you so much for your reply and I'm so happy you're doing well and recovered fully from chemo. I've been told so many different things from my doctors I guess I am really confused. The surgeon said the mitotic rate showed it was slow growing, and if chemo is for rapidly dividing cells, I dont understand how chemo would work. I also don't fully understand the oncotype test. If it says greater than 15 percent benefit of chemo ... is that specifically for me or a whole group of people that scored high? And how many out of 100 people actually benefit from chemo with high scores? Thank you for your feedback
Mitotic rate is subjective based on a lab person literally measuring. Different labs have different results. It's why most oncologists now base chemo on an oncotype score. And the 15% is for a group of people. No one can tell you what it will do for you personally. They can just tell you what it does for a bunch of people with your score.
Thank you so much
Hi @jenna1220x, and welcome again to our Community. We know understanding the risk and benefits of chemo is challenging, but you're receiving great information here. We wanted to also share with you this link you might find helpful from our site:
We hope this helps. Let us know how else we can support you!
—The Mods
hi jenna1220x
did you do chemo or decided not to.
@meow2024Hi! I did not do chemo. Despite my high oncotype score it did not seem right to me. I had a mitotic rate of 1. I have a 40 percent mucinous component and it can falsely elevate the invasion scores on the oncotype test making the tumor look more aggressive than it is. My single gene proliferation scores were not high on the oncotype test either. My oncologist initially recommended chemo based on a score of 37. When I presented all this information to him, he said I made a reasonable decision not to do chemo and my prognosis remains good, after telling me I had aggressive breast cancer solely based on my oncotype. I think its important that people look at their entire profile as a whole and not just one single test score when making treatment decisions. I also sought out a different oncologist, and he said even with a high oncotype, chemo would have had little benefit to me. The side effects would have outweighed the limited benefit in my situation. I have been on lupron and anastrazole for the past year and am doing well so far.
This is year 14 for me still NED
I have not looked at breast cancer dot org since 2016. I found our interaction on high oncotypes from that year. Congratulations on NED and not choosing chemo!!! My score was 39, surgery Jan 2012 and NED also. I did do chemo and sure wish I could have avoided it. Still a bit numb in the feet and my hair on top greatly thinned.
is this site still active? I just had a lumpectomy. ER+,PR-,HER2-, clear margins, node negative breast cancer DCIS - stage IA with a Ki-67 of 91-100% driving my oncotype score to 69! Tamoxifen is on my radar. Not sure if chemo. Trying to decide if it is worth the risk.
asoutherngirl, with that oncotype score you need to do chemo. Breast cancer does not just spread through the lymph nodes. The tumor can also release cells into the bloodstream before it's detected and those cells can rear their ugly heads years later to form a stage 4 disease. The more aggressive the tumor the more likely this was to happen and considering your oncotype score you had a very aggressive tumor. Chemo is designed to go after those errant cells and kill them. The more aggressive the cells the more effective chemo is so the good news is that you should have a very good response.
I just posted in the stage one forum a few minutes ago. This is the discussion I was looking for about Onco type scores. I was feeling good after surgery with Stage 1a ductal invasive and noninvasive estrogen positive with clear margins, no lymph nodes at 1cm. Thinking I would just do radiation and hormone therapy. I’m 57 years old. But got an onco score of 33. Dr recommended chemo AC 12 weeks and T 12 weeks. Anyone similar?