Join our Webinar: REAL Talk: Healthy Body and Mind After Breast Cancer Treatment - Jan 23, 2025 at 4pm ET Register here.

The dumbest things people have said to you/about you

1199200202204205333

Comments

  • PLJ
    PLJ Member Posts: 65
    edited January 2012

    Thanks for your ears!

  • mpeaches
    mpeaches Member Posts: 121
    edited January 2012

    PLJ - dear Lord!  I will admit to being thankful that my MIL crossed several years before my diagnosis, but yours really takes the cake!  I'm SO sorry!

    Astonished purrs,

    Jenn

  • Shrek4
    Shrek4 Member Posts: 519
    edited January 2012

    PLJ... you should have asked her right there on the spot "are you sure you grasped the meaning of "family"?

    Are you still talking to her after this?

  • Reality
    Reality Member Posts: 532
    edited January 2012

    Oh PLJ - How awful. How can people be so selfish. 

  • Annessister
    Annessister Member Posts: 7
    edited January 2012

    My sister told me I made it hard on her this summer by just sleeping and going to chemo "You should have let me do something for you!" She said I was a little selfish and really should think about others!!! I was just trying to get through it the best way I could. I refused to apologize for doing it my way- quietly and with just my dh and kids. It is hard enough being under everyones microscope let alone worrying if you don't ask for help you may be hurting someones feelings. CRAZY

  • chabba
    chabba Member Posts: 3,600
    edited January 2012

    PLJ - I too admit that I've thought a time or to that my MIL is no longer along but I doubt that she was bright enough to top that.  The worst thing she ever said to me was at a dinner one night at our house.  I was nearly forty and considering giving up on the fertility treatments we were trying (they never did work by the way).  She said "I've given up ever having grandchildren since it is obvious you and Nancy (her daughter who announced her pregnancy a week later) don't even want children."  I ran upstairs crying but felt better when I heard my DH telling her in his most controlled tone of voice what a thoughtless, insensitive, poor excuse of a Mother she was.  FIL and BIL both supported DH. 

  • Reality
    Reality Member Posts: 532
    edited January 2012

    Annessister - OMG - It is crazy!  I know our illness affects others, but it is still OUR illness. We have enough to do. So many people do not understand that just getting up in the morning is often a big challenge for us!  My ex-not-so-sig-other was complaining about how boring I had become - For the first time since diagnosis, I loudly and slowly stated, "I AM SICK". He responded with, "Well, I have been sick, too". (He had a cold...)

  • migallen
    migallen Member Posts: 46
    edited January 2012

    I agree people say themost insensitive stuff. My sil who works in a hospice had visited me after my bmx and she had been drinking, she cupped her breasts and said she was so glad to have her breasts and didnt know what sbe would do without them. My jaw just fell to the floor, my brother got onto her about her remark. You would think she would known better

  • Reality
    Reality Member Posts: 532
    edited January 2012

    migallen - Oh - I just cannot even imagine how you felt - so sorry you had to experience that insensitivity - So glad your brother stepped up. 

  • Jennt28
    Jennt28 Member Posts: 1,095
    edited January 2012

    WOW PLJ :-0



    My MIL is not great (thankful she's in another country) but yours... Guess when she's older and needs assistance you're off the hook though ;-)



    regards Jenn

  • kerrberlady
    kerrberlady Member Posts: 42
    edited January 2012

    Annessister, 

    That is how my SIL was the first DX in 2001. She and I were best friends and she said I was selfish for not letting her help more.  She was upset that my mom and dad were bringing food over so me and the kids could eat.  (I was going through a divorce at the time and my ex wasn't buying groceries for me or the kids, even though he was in the house still).  Finally after all my treatments and almost a full year later, I made her sit and talk to me about it.  It turned out that she was scared and didnt know how to react, since I was always "the rock" that held the family together.  I told her to take me off the pedestal.  I am fallable, and I was very hurt that she deserted me when I needed her the most and that in reality, she was the selfish one for walking away.  It took time, but we were able to get past it.  I wouldn't apologize for the way I handled it either, I did what I had to do, held my kids together, family and individual counseling, more for the divorce than the cancer, but they needed to talk about it with someone.  I don't get what goes through people's heads sometimes.   

  • barbe1958
    barbe1958 Member Posts: 7,605
    edited January 2012

    I don't feel sorry for the people who make these stupid comments, I feel PITY that they have to live inside their heads!! HOW do they look themselves in the mirror every morning??

    As for MIL's, I try SO hard to make sure I'm a good MIL. Whenever I see my son and his family I make a point of telling my DIL what a wonderful job she is doing with her baby and points like that. I don't make blanket comments, but make sure I pick something specific so she knows that I notice. Not sure if it means I'm seeing TOO much, but I'm just trying to support the way she runs her house. It IS her house, not mine. The other 2 are sons-in-law, so much easier to please!

  • PLJ
    PLJ Member Posts: 65
    edited February 2012
  • kmccraw423
    kmccraw423 Member Posts: 885
    edited January 2012

    What I would have liked was someone who said "I'm sorry this is happening to you.  What can I do to help?" and then give me a big hug.

  • LuvLulu07
    LuvLulu07 Member Posts: 596
    edited January 2012

     I will begin to navigate through the comments and questions in the next month and I'm dreading it.   I travelled far for medical care and surgery, so have not seen many of my friends and family for the past few months.  And I've had many friends that have not kept in touch at all - guess they're too fearful of dealing with the issues. 

    As far as the out-laws - they've been pretty outrageous for the past 20 years, so I'm not surprised at what I'm dealing with now.  I will need to set some boundaries though - BC has given me a bigger voice when dealing with foolishness and I won't hesitate to use it.   

  • barbe1958
    barbe1958 Member Posts: 7,605
    edited January 2012

    PLJ, I am SO proud of you!!! You know darn well that your FIL and SIL KNOW that she is a bitch. Good for you for mentioning the "unmentionable pink elephant in the room" - her weight!!!! ehehehhehehhehehe

    I know you must ache because you have lost what could have been a good relationship but will never be...I hope your DH sticks to you like glue!!!! 

    Happier New Year to all!!

  • PLJ
    PLJ Member Posts: 65
    edited January 2012

    Barbe1958: I felt your hug!

    Hugs,

    PLJ

  • NCbeachgal
    NCbeachgal Member Posts: 67
    edited January 2012

    My husband says when a complete stranger asks about the kind of cancer I have, my response should be, "the contagious kind." and then cough a little. They asked...

  • LuvLulu07
    LuvLulu07 Member Posts: 596
    edited January 2012

    NCbeachgal   Love that one - !! 

  • Reality
    Reality Member Posts: 532
    edited January 2012

    NCbeachgal - Thanks - perfect response!!

  • Annessister
    Annessister Member Posts: 7
    edited January 2012

    I love the contagious reply. Now I get "Are you in remission?" I say "I like to think of myself as cured, thanks for asking".

  • Reality
    Reality Member Posts: 532
    edited January 2012

    Oh yes - I get that one a lot - "are you in remission"?  My standard response has become, "Maybe" - noone has ever ventured to ask me anymore questions after that - most of them start planning their escape by slowly walking away and mummbling something like, "call me if you need anything". I know they want to say something supportive, but it is annoying when someone I barely know suggests that I call them - I do not even have their number! 

  • momof3boys
    momof3boys Member Posts: 63
    edited January 2012

    Here's my favorite: "God only gives us what we can bare, and you're such a strong person, I know you can handle this"....

    So, because I'm a strong person, God decided to give me BC? Really? That's my reward for being a strong, competent person?

  • riley702
    riley702 Member Posts: 575
    edited January 2012

    If someone asks "Are you in remission?" or "Are you OK now?", I just say "Sure hope so!" That usually shuts them down.

  • Eema
    Eema Member Posts: 403
    edited January 2012

    I am an occasional contributor to this forum, lurking enjoyably. What just stuck me that I'd like to share is cancer can be put into remission. There is no cure for stupid or rude or clueless.

  • rachelhmmd
    rachelhmmd Member Posts: 1
    edited January 2012

    I was explaining to my boss ( a female psychiatrist, as am I) that I had not expected to feel as terrible as I did about losing my hair, that I felt like I was disintegrating piece by piece,  and she said, "Well, that's ridiculous, at least you're alive."  The only time I wished my cancer on somebody else!

  • riley702
    riley702 Member Posts: 575
    edited January 2012

    Wow, what a clod! Your feelings are your feelings and ridicule just makes it worse.

  • lisa75
    lisa75 Member Posts: 6
    edited January 2012

    PLJ, your MIL sounds like My mom...minus the grossly overweight part. She has a habit of kicking people when they are down, and reminding people of their failures with a "see look what happened to you attitude"
    My mom called last night and I thought she was gonna say Happy New Year - so I said it first. Instead she asked how I was doing, and when I replied same as usual, she says "well, at least you are not sick!" (she has heart disease from smoking).

    I was about to tell her about my DCIS diagnosis but after that I'm not sure.

  • lisa69
    lisa69 Member Posts: 1
    edited January 2012

    my boss told me to get a breast reduction, after I just had both breast's just cut out of me do to DCIS ( I'm still having back problems because of my surgery)  from 2008 . 

  • Momine
    Momine Member Posts: 2,845
    edited January 2012

    Rachel, it is wonderful when a shrink is all understanding and empathetic like that :D